NYC PTET: A Practical Year-End Guide for S-Corps and Partnerships

Posted by Sundack CPA

November 29, 2025

On November 12, 2025

New York’s Pass-Through Entity Tax gets talked about a lot, but most S-Corp and partnership owners still aren’t sure if it actually helps them. They hear “NYC PTET saves taxes,” they check a box, and then hope it worked. Some win. Many don’t.

If you own an S-Corp or partnership in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, Staten Island, Nassau County, or Suffolk County, PTET is not something to guess on. It’s a year-end decision that needs real numbers behind it. When you run the right projection, NYC PTET can turn state and local income taxes into a larger federal deduction. When you don’t, it can shift tax and cash in ways you didn’t expect.

This guide is about how to look at PTET at year-end in a straightforward way, so you know whether to use it, skip it, or adjust how you’ve been handling it.

What NYC PTET Actually Does for Owners

In plain terms, PTET lets your S-Corp or partnership pay New York State tax at the entity level. That payment becomes a business expense, which reduces federal taxable income. The owners then receive a NYS PTET credit on their personal returns to offset what they would have paid individually.

For owners in NYC and on Long Island, where state and local taxes are high, that shift can matter. Instead of running into the federal SALT cap on your personal return, some of that tax comes through as a business deduction.

When NYC PTET works well:

your business has steady profit
owners live in New York and can use the credit
allocations between owners are clear
you have enough income for the federal deduction to matter

When it works poorly, it’s usually because someone elected PTET without running the math, or because there are nonresident owners who can’t use the NYS PTET credit correctly.

Who NYC PTET Usually Helps—and Who It Doesn’t

PTET tends to help:

S-Corp owners with high income in NYC or on Long Island
Partnerships with multiple New York–resident partners
Professional practices (medical, dental, law, consulting)
Real estate partnerships with solid positive income
IT firms and MSPs with strong recurring revenue

PTET often does not help:

S-Corps or partnerships with owners spread across many states
Entities with low or unstable profits
Structures with large losses or suspended losses
Situations where key owners aren’t subject to NY business taxes

The more your ownership is concentrated in NYC and Long Island residents, and the more predictable your profit is, the more likely PTET planning makes sense.

Why Year-End Is the Right Time to Look at PTET

You can’t make good PTET decisions in a vacuum. You need numbers. Year-end is the point in the year when the numbers stop moving as much:

revenue is mostly known
payroll is nearly final
owner draws and distributions are clear
major expenses have already hit
you can see the shape of the year, not just guesses

That makes December the right time to run a PTET projection. You’re close enough to your final profit to get a reliable answer, but still early enough to adjust payroll, distributions, or estimates if you need to.

Trying to figure NYC PTET out in March with no year-end plan is how owners end up surprised.

How to Judge If PTET Is Actually Saving You Money

The only honest way to evaluate PTET is to compare two scenarios:

business and owners with PTET
business and owners without PTET

That means building a year-end projection for:

S-Corp or partnership taxable income
owner wages (for S-Corps)
partner/shareholder allocations
owner residency (NYC, Long Island, out-of-state)
expected state tax without PTET
expected state tax with entity-level payments and a PTET credit

A good PTET review will show you three things:

total federal tax in each scenario
total NYS and NYC personal tax in each scenario
impact on cash and distributions

For NYC residents, the picture often tilts in favor of PTET because their NYS bill is higher and the federal deduction is more valuable. For Long Island owners in Nassau and Suffolk, it depends on income level and how much they’re already losing to the SALT cap.

If the “with PTET” scenario clearly lowers combined tax, the election can make sense. If the difference is tiny, or if any owner sees a worse result, it may not be worth the complexity.

How PTET Plays With S-Corp Payroll and Owner Pay

For S-Corp owners, NYC PTET doesn’t exist in isolation. It sits on top of three moving parts:

your salary
your distributions
your business profit after expenses

If reasonable compensation is too low, your S-Corp is already exposed on payroll. PTET won’t fix that. If your salary is higher than it needs to be, you may be paying more payroll tax than necessary, and PTET won’t fully make up the difference.

Year-end is when you:

check whether your salary is in a defensible range
true up distributions so they reflect actual profit after PTET
confirm that PTET payments are being treated as entity-level expenses, not random owner draws

In NYC and across Long Island, this review matters because S-Corp owners are often under more scrutiny—both from the IRS on wages and from New York on income reporting. A clean year-end payroll and pay structure makes PTET easier to model and safer to use.

What Partnerships Need to Watch With PTET

Partnerships deal with different PTET issues than S-Corps. Instead of salary and distributions, partnerships have capital accounts, special allocations, and multi-state filing to consider.

At year-end, a partnership PTET review should look at:

where each partner lives
how income is split among them
whether any partners cannot use NYS PTET credits
whether the partnership has multi-state activity
how PTET payments affect capital accounts

If you have a partner in Manhattan and another in New Jersey, for example, the NYC PTET election may help one more than the other. If one partner is a New York resident and another is not, you have to decide whether the entity-level tax makes sense for everyone—or whether you need a different allocation or structure.

Partnerships on Long Island that own real estate or operate in multiple states must be especially careful. If PTET planning ignores residency and allocations, the wrong partner ends up carrying a tax burden they didn’t expect.

Common PTET Mistakes in NYC and Long Island

Every year, the same problems show up:

electing PTET without a projection
missing how nonresident owners are affected
treating PTET like a guaranteed win instead of a case-by-case decision
not adjusting distributions to reflect PTET payments made by the entity
forgetting that PTET estimates need to be paid during the year

Another regular issue: owners flip PTET “on” one year, “off” the next, with no clear reason, or they keep it on even after profits drop. That kind of switching can create uneven results and makes long-term planning harder.

NYC PTET should be a deliberate part of your year-end plan, not a default setting.

Why Residency Drives So Much of the PTET Decision

For a PTET credit to mean anything, the owner has to be able to use it. That brings residency into the center of the conversation.

NYC residents generally see strong benefits when PTET is modeled correctly
Long Island residents often benefit as well, especially at higher income levels
nonresidents may not benefit at all

If an S-Corp or partnership is owned entirely by NYC and Long Island residents, the decision is simpler. If even one owner lives outside New York, you need to check whether that owner’s state respects the NYS PTET credit or not.

Residency shows up on every proper PTET workup because it changes how much benefit makes it to each owner’s personal return. Ignoring it is a mistake.

What a Practical Year-End PTET Review Looks Like

A good year-end PTET review isn’t a big project. It’s a focused pass through the right numbers at the right time. For most NYC and Long Island S-Corps and partnerships, that means:

getting books current through at least November
projecting final profit for the year
confirming payroll and, for S-Corps, reasonable compensation
listing each owner’s residency and interest in the entity
modeling tax with and without PTET

From there, the decision is usually clear. Either NYC PTET saves real money, or it doesn’t. Either all owners benefit, or some don’t. Either the election fits your structure, or it doesn’t.

Once you see that clearly on paper, you’re not guessing.

Talk Through PTET Before You Lock in 2025

NYC PTET is powerful when it’s used with intention. It’s a problem when it’s used by habit. S-Corp and partnership owners across NYC, Nassau, and Suffolk are in the window right now where a conversation about PTET still matters for 2025.

With current numbers, you can see:

whether PTET is worth it
what it does to your total federal and state bill
how it affects owner pay and distributions
how to handle 2025 estimates and 2026 planning

Once the year closes and deadlines pass, most of those options disappear.

Get a Year-End PTET Review for Your S-Corp or Partnership

If you own an S-Corp or partnership in NYC or on Long Island and you’re unsure whether PTET is helping you or not, a short, focused free consultation and review will give you a straight answer. With your real profit numbers, owner list, and residency, the picture becomes clear very quickly.

You don’t need a long project. You need a clean projection that shows your tax position with NYC PTET and without it—and what to change before the year ends.

Blog